• Home
  • About
    • Mission & History
    • Who We Serve
    • FHANC Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • Financials
    • Pillars of Anti-racism
  • What Is Fair Housing?
    • History of Fair Housing
    • Federal Fair Housing Rights
    • California and Local Fair Housing Rights
    • Housing Industry Resources
    • Fair Housing Resources
    • April: Fair Housing Month
  • Audit Investigations & Reports
  • Programs and Services
    • For Renters
    • For Homeowners - Foreclosure Prevention
    • Education >
      • Fair Housing Literature
      • Community Outreach
      • School Programs
    • Education for Homebuyers
    • Advocacy & AFFH
  • Service Areas
    • Marin County
    • Solano County
    • Sonoma County
    • Other Geographic Areas
  • News & Events
    • In The News
    • Press Releases & Statements
    • Events & Workshops
    • FHANC Newsletters
    • Fair Housing Conference 2023
    • Fair Housing Conference 2022
    • Fair Housing Conference 2021
    • COVID-19 Panel
    • Fair Housing Conference 2020
    • Fair Housing Conference 2019
    • Fair Housing Conference 2018
  • Donate
    • Main Donation Page
    • Cy Pres Awards
    • Vehicle Donations
    • More Ways to Give
  • Get Involved
    • Job Opportunities
    • Become an Investigator
    • Join Our Board
    • Volunteer Opportunities
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Request Assistance
    • Privacy Policy
    • Education Programs
  • Fair Housing Conference 2025
  • Poetry Contest 2024
Fair Housing Advocates of Northern California
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission & History
    • Who We Serve
    • FHANC Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • Financials
    • Pillars of Anti-racism
  • What Is Fair Housing?
    • History of Fair Housing
    • Federal Fair Housing Rights
    • California and Local Fair Housing Rights
    • Housing Industry Resources
    • Fair Housing Resources
    • April: Fair Housing Month
  • Audit Investigations & Reports
  • Programs and Services
    • For Renters
    • For Homeowners - Foreclosure Prevention
    • Education >
      • Fair Housing Literature
      • Community Outreach
      • School Programs
    • Education for Homebuyers
    • Advocacy & AFFH
  • Service Areas
    • Marin County
    • Solano County
    • Sonoma County
    • Other Geographic Areas
  • News & Events
    • In The News
    • Press Releases & Statements
    • Events & Workshops
    • FHANC Newsletters
    • Fair Housing Conference 2023
    • Fair Housing Conference 2022
    • Fair Housing Conference 2021
    • COVID-19 Panel
    • Fair Housing Conference 2020
    • Fair Housing Conference 2019
    • Fair Housing Conference 2018
  • Donate
    • Main Donation Page
    • Cy Pres Awards
    • Vehicle Donations
    • More Ways to Give
  • Get Involved
    • Job Opportunities
    • Become an Investigator
    • Join Our Board
    • Volunteer Opportunities
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Request Assistance
    • Privacy Policy
    • Education Programs
  • Fair Housing Conference 2025
  • Poetry Contest 2024

RE: Report on Fair Housing Investigation Uncovers National Origin and Source ofIncome Discrimination

5/28/2021

9 Comments

 
April 26, 2021
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
 
Contacts:
Caroline Peattie / [email protected]
 
RE: Report on Fair Housing Investigation Uncovers National Origin and Source of
Income Discrimination
 
As Fair Housing Month draws to a close, and Fair Housing Advocates of Northern California
(FHANC) gears up for its annual Fair Housing Conference on Thursday, April 29 (“Riding the
Wave of Change: Advancing Fair Housing and Equity in a New Era,”), it is releasing its
report of an investigation conducted in 2020, “National Origin and Source of Income
Discrimination in Rental Housing in Marin, Sonoma, and Solano Counties.” The
investigation was conducted after California SB329 – amending the Fair Employment and
Housing Act to expand the definition of source of income to include federal, state, and local
public assistance and housing subsidies – went into effect on January 1, 2020.
 
The investigation followed a prior audit in 2018-2019 that assessed the extent to which Housing
Choice Voucher holders experienced race discrimination, and was conducted prior to the state
law going into effect. The investigation revealed a high level of discrimination, where 67% of
tests showed at least some level of discrimination based on race and/or source of income.
 
“Given how much race and source of income discrimination we found with our earlier
investigation, we wanted to see the extent to which Latinx Housing Choice Voucher holders
experience discrimination or differential treatment in the initial stages of their home seeking
process, based on their voucher status or their national origin,” said Caroline Peattie, Executive
Director of FHANC. “We know from our clients that many landlords turn away voucher
holders, but we wanted to see to what extent this occurred, and whether it was a pretext for
discouraging Latinx renters.”
 
FHANC conducted 139 individual investigations, 48 in Marin County, 46 in Solano County,
and 45 in Sonoma County. The investigation revealed housing providers discriminated on the
basis of national origin and/or source of income in approximately seventy-nine percent (79%) of
the time. Of the tests revealing discrimination, 55% were based on source of income, 13% were
based on both source of income and national origin, and 11% were based on national origin.
Examples of the types of discrimination that investigators encountered included outright refusal
to rent to voucher holders; discriminatory policies (like minimum income requirement) that
effectively prohibit voucher holders from renting at the property; and/or inferior
terms/conditions and general treatment to Latinx voucher holders as compared to white (non-
Latinx) voucher holders.
 
“What is particularly problematic about this result is the high rate of discrimination against
voucher holders that occurred even after the passage of SB329,” said Peattie. “And though our
investigation in Marin County revealed the lowest levels of discrimination at 71% in the tricounty
area, that’s still extremely high, particularly considering that local source of income
protections had been in place since 2016 in the County and 2018 in various cities and towns.
The investigation shows that it’s still very difficult for someone with a housing subsidy to find a
place to live, and it becomes that much harder for a voucher holder who is Latinx.”
 
As a result of follow-up investigation and after receiving a complaint from a client who had
been effectively denied from renting because she had a housing voucher, FHANC recently filed
a lawsuit against a management company and the owners of two buildings in Sonoma County
for having a minimum income policy that – while neutral on its face as applied to voucher
holders – has the effect of denying them the ability to rent at the property, despite
management’s assurances that they accept vouchers.
 
“It’s not enough just to pass legislation,” said Peattie. “That’s the first, most important step. But
our results point to the need for further education, as well as follow-up investigation and
enforcement activity to ensure that landlords understand the laws and are held accountable
when they deliberately violate them. To that end we’ve sent flyers with information about the
law to properties where we found discrimination. And we’re undertaking further investigations
to retest some of the properties. But we need to go further with legislation, too.”
 
Only twelve states and the District of Columbia outlaw discrimination on the basis of source of
income. The Biden administration, in a swift reversal from the previous administration, signaled
fair housing and racial equity as priorities in its first week. This month, President Biden pledged
to restore two Obama-era fair housing rules that had been scrapped under the Trump
administration. One, the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) rule, requires local
governments receiving federal housing dollars to review their policies and actively work toward
reversing segregation.
 
“Protections against source of income discrimination are crucial in order to affirmatively
furthering fair housing, because it helps stem the tide of displacement and gentrification,”
 
Peattie continued. “We undertook this investigation and the previous one to uncover the extent
to which people with housing subsidies, particularly people of color with housing subsidies,
experienced barriers to housing choice. We now have a sense of just how great those
impediments are, despite local and state protections. This shows how important it is for the
federal government to make source of income discrimination illegal across the country, so that
the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Office of Fair Housing and Equal
Opportunity can put its full strength toward enforcing the law, furthering housing opportunities
for people of color, families with children, people with disabilities, and others. It would be a
fitting tribute to Walter Mondale, who passed away earlier this month, and who co-authored the
Fair Housing Act of 1968 with Senator Ed Brooke.”
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: This material is based on work supported by the Department of Housing and Urban
Development (HUD) under FHIP EOI Grant FEOI20012. Any opinion, findings, and
conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do
not necessarily reflect the views of HUD.
 
Founded as a non-profit in 1986, Fair Housing Advocates of Northern California (FHANC)
serves several Bay Area counties, providing fair housing counseling, investigation, intervention,
and legal referrals to persons experiencing housing discrimination. FHANC conducts outreach
activities and offers programs that educate the community about fair housing and the value of
diversity, conducts trainings for housing providers, and offers pre-purchase and foreclosure
prevention counseling and education. FHANC is a HUD-Certified Housing Counseling
Agency. Please contact FHANC at (415) 457-5025 or TDD: (800) 735-2922 for more
information or visit www.fairhousingnorcal.org. Se habla español.
9 Comments
Rochelle Brown
7/8/2021 10:56:23 pm

I filed a complaint with HUD/DFEH last year for retaliation, discrimination, harassment and personal injury. I was denied a Reasonable Accommodation by my apartment complex, Westview Ranch. I was in a car accident 2/27/20 and sustained 2 broken ankles leg and hand injury. DFEH has allowed this and are believing all their lies. I was forced to move after maintenance watered down my apartment. I had to file a police report, I came home to no power in my apartment, which SMUD stated someone manually shut it off. They inspected fire sprinklers in all units except mine. I lived on the third level, and was in a wheelchair that’s why I needed an Accommodation. I fell down the stairs twice and re-injured my injuries. There’s so much I really need help in making them accountable, my Civil Rights are being violated.

Reply
Annya Maskey, Executive Assistant and Development Coordinator
7/12/2021 03:47:41 pm

Hello Rochelle,

Thank you for sharing your story with us. Unfortunately, Fair Housing Advocates of Northern California cannot provide any counseling through the comments of our website. We would like to contact you regarding your complaint and concerns of your fair housing rights. Please email or call me and I can get you connected with our intake coordinator. My email address is [email protected] and my direct line is 415-483-7566. You can also call our main line also. That number is 415-457-5025.

Take care,
Annya

Reply
Outsource Agency Philippines link
2/7/2022 06:58:59 pm

Great article! This blog deserves numbers of reader, thank you so much for sharing us this amazing work.

Reply
Belnap Builders LLC link
8/11/2024 01:59:03 am

The blog’s report on the fair housing investigation reveals crucial findings of discrimination based on national origin and source of income, highlighting systemic issues that need addressing.

Reply
Eternal Fences link
12/25/2024 08:14:24 am

Eternal Fences specializes in crafting and installing premium fencing solutions tailored to enhance the security, privacy, and aesthetic appeal of residential and commercial properties.

Reply
AUUA News link
12/30/2024 04:44:33 pm

Stay informed with AUUA News, your go-to source for the latest breaking news, analysis, and insightful commentary on global and local events.

Reply
AUUA Sports link
1/1/2025 04:08:14 pm

Stay updated with the latest cricket match, live cricket scores, cricket news ,cricket highlights, and expert analysis at AUUA Sports.

Reply
AUUA News link
1/2/2025 03:07:16 pm

Stay informed with AUUA News, your go-to source for the latest breaking news, analysis, and insightful commentary on global and local events.

Reply
AUUA Sports link
1/4/2025 01:37:32 pm

Stay updated with the latest cricket match, live cricket scores, cricket news ,cricket highlights, and expert analysis at AUUA Sports.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2025
    September 2024
    July 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    December 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    October 2022
    August 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    March 2020
    August 2019
    March 2019
    November 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    August 2017
    July 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016

Picture
Mailing Address:
851 Irwin Street
​Suite 218
San Rafael, CA 94901

Note: we no longer meet with clients in person as most of our staff work remotely.
Phone 415.457.5025
Fax 415.457.6382
Staff Directory
Contact Us
Picture
TDD: (800) 735-2922
Se habla español
​
We welcome our site visitors with content in Spanish and Vietnamese.
En Espanol
TIẾNG VIỆT

Programs & Services
For Renters 
For Homeowners
Education for Homebuyers
Housing Industry Resources
Community Outreach
Advocacy & AFFH
Fair Housing Literature
Sign up for our Newsletter
Make a donation
Volunteer form
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission & History
    • Who We Serve
    • FHANC Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • Financials
    • Pillars of Anti-racism
  • What Is Fair Housing?
    • History of Fair Housing
    • Federal Fair Housing Rights
    • California and Local Fair Housing Rights
    • Housing Industry Resources
    • Fair Housing Resources
    • April: Fair Housing Month
  • Audit Investigations & Reports
  • Programs and Services
    • For Renters
    • For Homeowners - Foreclosure Prevention
    • Education >
      • Fair Housing Literature
      • Community Outreach
      • School Programs
    • Education for Homebuyers
    • Advocacy & AFFH
  • Service Areas
    • Marin County
    • Solano County
    • Sonoma County
    • Other Geographic Areas
  • News & Events
    • In The News
    • Press Releases & Statements
    • Events & Workshops
    • FHANC Newsletters
    • Fair Housing Conference 2023
    • Fair Housing Conference 2022
    • Fair Housing Conference 2021
    • COVID-19 Panel
    • Fair Housing Conference 2020
    • Fair Housing Conference 2019
    • Fair Housing Conference 2018
  • Donate
    • Main Donation Page
    • Cy Pres Awards
    • Vehicle Donations
    • More Ways to Give
  • Get Involved
    • Job Opportunities
    • Become an Investigator
    • Join Our Board
    • Volunteer Opportunities
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Request Assistance
    • Privacy Policy
    • Education Programs
  • Fair Housing Conference 2025
  • Poetry Contest 2024